Hirshleifer, David, and Tyler Shumway, “Good Morning Sunshine: Stock Returns and the Weather,” The Journal of Finance, Vol 58, No 3 (2003), 1009-1032.
- Weather (days of sunshine) is a truly exogenous variable
- Sunshine in the cities of 26 countries’ largest stock exchanges strongly and statistically significantly predicts stock returns between 1982 and 1997
- After controlling for days of sunshine, other weather patterns such as rain and snow have no effect.
- Trading based on the weather would be optimal for a trader facing very low transaction costs, but even moderate costs would generally prohibit such a strategy.
- These results are consistent with a theory of mood affecting behavior, but are not consistent with the theory of rational actors.
- Table III: The joint betas are significant. This might be driven by the large but insignificant betas for Buenos Aires and Rio de Janeiro (Sao Paolo; see below)
- Hirshleifer & Shumway mistakenly collected weather data for Rio de Janeiro, while their return data comes from the Brazil’s largest stock exchange (Sao Paolo).